Family Heirloom:
Best in Show

Story by Lance Oliver, photos by Richard Ried

October 9, 2004 – All the motorcycles in the annual Motorcycle Hall of Fame Museum Concours d'Elegance are links to the past. But Kenneth Minnich's impeccably restored 1936 Indian Four represents a tie to his own family history that he could never put a price tag on.

"My father always had two or three motorcycles around, and Indians were his favorite," says Minnich. Among the bikes his father, Paul Minnich, left behind were two partially disassembled Indian Fours.

With the help of the father-son team of John and Tony Morozowsky, the parts were catalogued and a concours-quality restoration was begun. The work stretched over two and a half years.

Almost as many hours went into research as were spent on the hands-on work of the restoration. Tony found some paint inside the bodywork that was not badly faded, and used a spectrometer to create an exact match to the 1936 Indian "Mohawk green" hue. He found a wiring diagram to make sure that the wires were the original colors.

Meanwhile, John rebuilt the engine, including fabrication of missing parts that were needed, including the unique dual exhaust which appeared on the Indian Four only in 1936 and 1937. That model was also the first Indian with a brake light.

The result is a stunning and unique motorcycle that recently was awarded a rating of 99.5 on a scale of 100 by Antique Motorcycle Club of America judges.

But more than a collector's item, for Minnich it's an irreplaceable family heirloom and a priceless tie to his late father.

"I've been offered six figures for it, by a young Philadelphia lawyer who saw it at a show," says Minnich. "I said I'd talk to him all he wanted about the bike, but if he brought up money, I wouldn't talk to him any more. It's just something personal to me."

Minnich will now take custody for one year of the Jim Davis Best In Show Award traveling trophy, which bears the names of the winners in each of the Concours d'Elegance held as part of the Museum's annual Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony weekend.

At right is a complete list of all the award winners.

2004 Motorcycle Hall of Fame Museum Concours d'Elegance Winners

Best in Show:
1936 Indian Four
Kenneth Minnich

Preservation Award
1970 BSA Lighting
John Lovat

American Early
1st Jim Rauck
  1912 Harley-Davidson
2nd Tom McKee
  1929 Harley JDH
3rd Gary McMahon
  1942 Indian Chief

American Late
1st Marcie McMahon
  1965 Harley 165
2nd Keith and Norma Fletcher
  1970 Harley Servicar
3rd Steve Rosenstein
  1957 HD Sportster

British Early
1st Gene Brown
  1938 Brough Superior
2nd Gene Brown
  1954 Vincent Black Shadow
3rd Bob McClean
  1928 Scott Super Squirrel

British Late
1st Jerry Peters
  1970 Triumph T100R Daytona
2nd Barb Kybena
  1967 Triumph Cub
3rd Jim Godo
  1974 TR5T Triumph

European
1st Peter Calles
  1962 Ducati Mach I
2nd Peter Calles
  1972 Ducati 750 Sport
3rd Tom Reddy
  1965 BMW R695

Japanese Early
1st Frank Haney
  Honda CL 72
2nd Larry Barnes
  Honda CL77
3rd Terry Mitchell
  Honda CL 77

Japanese Late
1st Steve Passwater
  1975 Honda CB 400F
2nd Steve Passwater
  1975 CB 400F
3rd Larry Ralston
  1975 Honda Gold Wing

Competition Early
1st Jim Godo
  1966 Matchless 685CS
2nd Phil Franz
  1934 HD Hillclimber
3rd Jim Oldiges
  HD XR750

Competition Late
1st Terry Mitchell
  Bultaco Astro
2nd Steve Penningson
  Honda XR75
3rd Kerry Kybena
  1976 Bultaco Sherpa

Specials & Customs
1st Don Sherman
  1972 Triumph
2nd Larry McGuire
  1952 Harley Hydraglide
3rd Steve Clinton
  1975 Norton


Scenes from the Third Annual Motorcycle Hall of Fame Museum Concours d'Elegance


First and second place winners in the Japanese Late class, a pair of 1975 CB400F Supersports, both owned by Steve Passwater.


There was no shortage of fine machinery in the British classes.


First place, Special and Custom: a tidy cafe racer based on a 1972 Triumph owned by Don Sherman.


Third place, Early Competition. Jim Oldiges and his XR750.


First place, European. Peter Calles' 1962 Ducati Mach I.


Third Place, Japanese Late. Larry Ralston and his 1975 Honda Gold Wing.


Saddled-up and ready to ride. Who says a show bike can't be a runner?


Long-time museum supporters Mike and Margaret Wilson (right) with Keith Fletcher and his Harley Servicar.


Gene Brown's 1938 Brough Superior SS 80. First place, British Early.


Tank art on Larry McGuire's 1952 Harley-Davison Hydraglide.


Gene Brown's other entry, a 1954 Vincent Black Shadow, took second place, British Early.


Not all the classic machinery was entered in the concours, as this touring Vincent spotted in the parking lot demonstrates.

© 2004, American Motorcyclist Association